Str8-To-Gay: The Plea Bargain (Tony Newport & Shay Michaels)

The Plea Bargain (Tony Newport & Shay Michaels) at Str8ToGay.com

The Plea Bargain (Tony Newport & Shay Michaels) at Str8ToGay.com

The Plea Bargain (Tony Newport & Shay Michaels) at Str8ToGay.com

The Plea Bargain (Tony Newport & Shay Michaels) at Str8ToGay.com

The Plea Bargain (Tony Newport & Shay Michaels) at Str8ToGay.com


Tony Newport is a recently busted shoplifting bad boy who is facing some serious jail time. Shay Michaels makes a direct offer to drop the charges, but first Tony will have to go from Str8 to gay!

Watch Tony Newport & Shay Michaels at Men.com

jinger says:

Bottom is not so bad, but no, I don’t like them.

manu says:

Both are hot but they are both gay.
Shay should also ALWAYS bottom.

topher says:

This site has had some really hot men having really hot sex. Sorry, but this video has neither.

landreau says:

This scene just underscores why men.com is so disappointing. Shay is versatile, but on any other site he’d be the bottom. Men.com is almost always about a little guy getting fucked by a bigger, older, more masculine guy. Can’t they feature more masculine big guys on the bottom?!!!

itavaldego says:

There are only negative opinions in reply. But I’m not. I’ve heard that Tony barely bottoms, but he did in this video! I’m glad about that! I donno about Top…so pass! I wanna see Tony to bottom more and more!

Daniel says:

Another blah update.