i don’t see ANYthing wrong with two adult concenting brothers having sex with each other. i think if you look at it objectively, incest is wrong in just a few cases: where there is a power situation (i.e. one or both are not in a position to say ‘no’), where 5-legged babies can be produced, and where one or both can be hurt. but if you think about it, that is what defines ‘wrong’ in any kind of sexual relationship. any other sense of it being ‘wrong’ is purely subjective tradition.

so please, i challenge you to explain, in objective terms, what is ‘wrong’ with it, other than to say, “it just is” – i.e. other than to use exactly the same arguments homophobes use about homosexuality.

perhaps you’re just projecting you and your brother into this situation, and that’s distasteful to you. that’s fine, i’m not ADVOCating anyone engage in sex with their brother, just that i don’t think it is per sé wrong.

@cf – tell me, objectively, what would be wrong with it. it’s an interesting thing to think about, because the arguments typically forwarded are exactly the ones used against gay relationships…

So you’re basically suggesting that the two twins fuck each other? It’s that sort of thing that makes homophobes equate our sexuality with incest, pedophilia, bestiality, etc., labeling it a “deviant,” continuing to oppress our community that we’re freaks of nature. There is NOTHING sexy or desirable about incest. I’m sad to see that a few gay folks actually get off to that sort of thing.