Nicholas Michaels is preparing Thanksgiving dinner before heading out to a costume party. His stepdad, Cole Connor, dressed as a rather sexy pilgrim, walks into the kitchen unexpectedly, startling him and making him spill gravy on his shirt. Embarrassed, Nicholas asks Cole to keep an eye on the food while he rushes off to change. A mischievous Cole, eager to prank his stepson before he heads out, climbs on top of the kitchen counter and sticks his dick on a pie Nicholas made. The warm feeling of the stuffing on his dick makes Cole horny, so he starts fucking the pie until Nicholas comes back, now dressed as a turkey. Surprised, he asks his stepdad about his curious cooking method. Thinking fast, Cole tells his boy he is actually seasoning the pie with his “secret ingredient” and offers Nicholas the chance to taste it before leaving. The twink in the turkey costume follows his stepdad's lead only to end up getting his hole nice and pounded before his party.