Bait Buddies sets the hook early as Max SexyStache returns to the studio talking big appetites and even bigger expectations, quickly catching the attention of confident newcomer Lenny Fuego. What starts as a planned threesome takes a sharp turn when plans fall through, leaving two bold egos, a tempting offer, and a dare that changes everything. With Caruso upping the stakes, Max turns on the charm and Lenny faces a choice that pushes him far outside his comfort zone. The tension builds fast as bravado, curiosity, and raw temptation collide, proving that at Bait Buddies, the biggest surprises come when plans go off script.