Nick Capra invites Tony Salerno up to his cabin to make their meeting more private. Tony feels bad about keeping this a secret from his wife. Agreeing to keep their encounter between them, Tony starts to wonder if Nick is only doing this for the fantasy of doing a straight guy, or if it means something more. To reassure him, Nick sits closer to him and admits that he doesn't want to get his heart broken as well, considering how Tony could go back to his wife and never look back.

Nick then places his hand behind Tony's head and leans in for a kiss. Forgetting about their uncertainties, they start to make out passionately. Nick lays on top of Tony to hold him down while he feels Tony's body. They slowly start taking their clothes off, piece by piece, until only their skin touch. Nick gets on his knees and brings his big cock near Tony's face. Tony is sucking on Nick's uncut dick, getting it all wet. Then Nick decides it's time to pleasure the straight guy by turning him over and spreading his ass cheeks to rim Tony's hole. After loosening up his hole with his tongue, Nick enters his hard thick cock inside of Tony, fucking him while looking deeply into his eyes. Both guys finish by jerking off and shooting their cum all over their hairy bodies.