Beefcake Hunter: Andrew’s First Anal Ever

Andrew's First Anal Ever at Beefcake Hunter

Andrew's First Anal Ever at Beefcake Hunter
Andrew's First Anal Ever at Beefcake Hunter
Andrew's First Anal Ever at Beefcake Hunter

Andrew’s First Anal Ever at Beefcake Hunter:

At Beefcake Hunter, we love breaking in first-timers, and Andrew delivers an unforgettable debut. In his own words, this was his first anal experience ever—and he handled it like a natural. Instead of nerves, he brought confidence, curiosity, and undeniable sex appeal, making for an electrifying encounter.

A Tease Worth Watching:

With a chiseled physique and irresistible charm, Andrew’s striptease set the mood, leaving little to the imagination. As he teased himself to a semi-hard state, it didn’t take long for me to jump in and take over. Starting with his sensitive balls, I worked my way up, pulling deep moans as I pleasured him. Though I tried to get him to face-fuck me, it seems he’s saving that for another time.

Taking the Next Step:

Eager to see how his first anal experience would unfold, we moved to the sofa. After some playful foreplay, I guided him through his first-ever deep thrusts. He took his time, pushing in slowly but firmly, focusing on every movement as he sank into me. It didn’t take long before he found his rhythm, going harder and deeper, fully in the zone.

Finishing with a Bang:

Andrew’s stamina held up as he picked up the pace, his big cock drilling me with growing intensity. The heat built to an explosive climax as he poured his thick, warm load all over my ass—a perfect ending to his first-time experience. And, of course, we couldn’t resist continuing the fun in the shower, where I got to admire his sculpted body one last time.

Don’t miss Andrew’s first anal experience—only at Beefcake Hunter!

Watch as Andrew Fucks Vic at Beefcake Hunter

Watch as Andrew Fucks Vic at Beefcake Hunter

Mark Coppola says:

Wow…he looks a LOT like Luigi Mangione!

Chase Justice says:

Wow, he’s insanely hot! Tall, dark, and just straight-up gorgeous. Would love to see him loosen up a bit more in the future maybe talk a little more? But honestly, no complaints at all!

Chase Justice says:

Wow, he’s insanely hot! Tall, dark, and just straight-up gorgeous. Would love to see him loosen up a bit more in the future maybe talk a little more? But honestly, no complaints at all!

Semafor says:

Andrew might’ve been pretty quiet during this scene, but damn, he still made it unforgettable! His sweet personality, killer smile, and overall build had me hooked.

That striptease? Absolute fire. 🔥 Now, just imagine if he had a little more tan and grew out his bush a bit—perfection! There’s just something about that military background that makes him even hotter.

That superhero pose while getting head? Iconic. 💪 And for someone with zero prior anal experience, he looked insanely good taking care of business. Slow and steady really works for him—matches his quiet vibe perfectly.

Psyched that he’s coming back! Maybe next time, we’ll get a couch POV and some missionary action? 👀